Former Bemus Point, Gerry Commercial Buildings Sold
- 4003 Rt. 380, Gerry was sold in early February for $115,000. This had been the location of Backyard Bar and Grill.
- 6 Main St., Bemus Point was sold in early February for $475,000. This had been the location of Treasurers on Main. P-J photos by Gregory Bacon

4003 Rt. 380, Gerry was sold in early February for $115,000. This had been the location of Backyard Bar and Grill.
Two commercial buildings that no longer have businesses operating out of them have been sold.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Feb. 3-10.
During this time period, 6 Main of Bemus Point, LLC of Somerville, Mass. sold 6 Main St., Bemus Point to Makesmiths LLC of Tarentum, Pa. for $475,000. That was the location of Treasurers On Main. On Facebook, the business announced it was closing in December due to the building being sold.
Also during this time period, Teel Wolcott sold 4003 Route 380, Gerry to Route 380, LLC of Kennedy for $115,000. That was the location of Backyard and Bar & Grill. On Facebook, it was announced that a “Backyard Closing Party” took place Jan. 25.
In a separate sale, Falconer Property 137, LLC of Falconer sold 137 S. Work St., Falconer to Wall to Wall of WNY, LLC of Falconer for $397,000. That is the location of Jamestown Auto Parts, which continues to operate out of that location.

6 Main St., Bemus Point was sold in early February for $475,000. This had been the location of Treasurers on Main. P-J photos by Gregory Bacon
Including the sales previously mentioned, from Feb. 3-10 there were eight sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 2744 Shadyside Road, Mina sold for $850,000.
– 63 West 17th St., 57 West 17th St., and two other parcels on West 17th Street, Jamestown sold for $499,000.
– 10567 Chestnut Road, Dunkirk town sold for $330,000.
– 295 E. Terrace Ave., Lakewood sold for $329,900.
– 5438 Stockton-Hartfield Road, Stockton sold for $300,000.
– 2923 Route 394, North Harmony sold for $291,375.
Overall, from Feb. 3-10 there were 109 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
Robert Milk sold 4948 Route 60, Gerry to Kathleen Barmore for $30,500.
Falconer Property 137, LLC of Falconer sold S. 137 Work St., Falconer to Wall to Wall of WNY, LLC of Falconer for $397,000.
K&M Nordwall Family Trust II sold 4121 Cowing Road, Busti to Mark and Stacey Nordwall for $180,000.
John Hangartner and Caroline Appleby sold 474 Bentley Hill Road, Ellington to Joseph Caldwell and Tracy Sassi for $10,000.
The Datesman Family Trust sold Home 2B, NorthShore at Chautauqua, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Chautauqua for $20,000.
Stephen and Natasha Schwartz sold 5438 Stockton-Hartfield Road, Stockton to Donald Telecky for $300,000.
Jade Walsh sold 5077 Summerdale Road, Chautauqua town to Chelsea Mosure for $120,000.
Joshua Walker sold 5441 & 5437 Washington St., Harmony to JTM Ventures, LLC of Ashville for $15,000.
Mark and Michelle Odebralski sold 22 Lodi St., Forestville, town of Hanover, to Cassidy Buchman for $180,000.
Teel Wolcott sold 4003 Route 380, Gerry to Route 380, LLC of Kennedy for $115,000.
Carlos and Arielina Lizarraga sold 209 King St., Dunkirk to Carols Manuel Brunet for $115,000.
A referee for the Housing and Urban Development sold 27 Central Ave., Brocton to KC Buffalo Enterprises, LLC and Western New York Business Ventures, Inc. for $59,131.
James Weise sold 206 Park St., Sherman to Sheila Keeler for $235,000.
PPP Future Development Inc. of Alexander, NY sold 3326 Sprague Hill Road, Poland to Jason and Joanna Foster for $115,000.
A legal guardian for Thomas Hammer sold a parcel on Route 76, Ripley to Mark Gajkowski for $45,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Peter Smith sold 5131 Sherman-Mayville Road, Chautauqua town to James and Nicole Rogers for $160,000.
Charles Swanson Jr. sold 16 Maltby St., Jamestown to Mark and Andrea Arakelian for $121,000.
Oscar and Karla Santos sold 3826 Franklin Ave., Dunkirk town to Veronice Jones for $54,000.
6 Main of Bemus Point, LLC of Somerville, Mass. sold 6 Main St., Bemus Point to Makesmiths, LLC of Tarentum, Pa. for $475,000.
John and Donna Mackenzie sold three parcels on Beck Road, Ellery to Oscar Peterson for $25,000.
Roy and Joseph Orton sold a parcel on Hamilton Road, Ripley to Cortenay Semelka for $40,000.
Bryant Gauggel sold 50 W. Ninth St., Jamestown to Joshua Vanord for $8,000.
Gloria Corredor sold 25 Burton Ave., Ripley to the MD Mazharul Islam Shawn Revocable Trust for $21,000.
The executrix of the Last Will and Testament of Samuel Ark sold a parcel on Route 5, Sheridan to Andrew Munch for $19,169.
Andrew Elderkin sold 7455 Putnam Road, Stockton to Nathanael Stanford for $99,000.
LNG Enterprises, Inc. of Fredonia sold 10136 Rt. 60, Pomfret to Geoffrey and Amber Felt for $55,000.
Douglas and David Macfadden sold 438 Lake Shore Drive West, Dunkirk to David and Jill Macfadden for $150,000.
The executrix of the Estate of Becky Weber sold 63 West 17th St., 57 West 17th St., and two other parcels on West 17th Street, Jamestown to Zackary Emmick for $499,000.
Donald Piglowski sold 10567 Chestnut Road, Dunkirk town to Jeffrey Hover for $330,000.
Daniel and Rebecca Morgan sold 2923 Route 394, North Harmony to Andrew Manrique for $291,375.
Douglas and Jonathon Pendl sold 123 Ruggles St., Dunkirk to Jared Miernik Jr. for $25,000.
Robert Gray sold 760 Harrington Road, Carroll to Atlee and Elizabeth Byler for $29,400.
Katherine Best sold 81 Elm St., Jamestown to Bradley Fisher for $55,000.
Gooseneck Farms Inc. of Bemus Point sold a parcel on Lewis Road, Ellery to Gerald Possai, Julie Possai, Erik Possai and Anna Tryniak for $110,000.
The trustees of the George H. Littlefield and Beverly T. Littlefield Irrevocable Asset Protection Trust sold 760 Harrington Road, Carroll to Atlee and Elizabeth Byler for $40,000.
The executrix of the Last Will and Testament of Claudette Baldwin sold a parcel on School Street, Villenova to Larry and Arlene Dahn for $3,000.
U.S. Bank Trust NA sold 29 Franklin St., Westfield to Michael and John Mackay for $214,000.
Cheryl Grzegorzewski, Robin Frazita, Charles Tilley, Mark Tilley, Lindsay Ivey and Gale Young sold 304 Franklin Ave., Dunkirk to Yvonne Rosario for $92,000.
Sydnee and Thomas Ball sold 28 Campbell Ave., Jamestown to Seth Ramey for $145,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Salvatore J. Lisciandro sold 3443 Route 430, Ellery to David and Lynn Trathen for $227,555.
David Lipari sold 100 Hazzard St., Jamestown to Austin Olson for $76,750.
A referee for the heirs of Mary Helene Williams sold 3948 S. Everett Ave., Ellery to Chautauqua Solutions, LLC of Bemus Point for $83,043.
Caroline and Marvin Bader sold 301 South Ave., Busti to Robert and Karla Halbohm for $225,000.
Dale Shavalier, Scott Flagg, and Robert Perrine sold 6260 Honeysette Road, Chautauqua town to Robert Steinjan Jr. and Robert Steinjan III for $114,900.
Richard and Teri Stalter sold 131 Chestnut St., Westfield to Aydin Mitchell for $198,500.
Carol Sommer sold 81 Otter St., Dunkirk to Roger Greeley for $215,000.
Michael and Barbara King sold 295 E. Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Tammy Mangus for $329,900.
Richard Ciraulo sold 329 Dove St. and a parcel on Plover Street, Dunkirk to Kenneth Jurek for $168,000.
Ashley Winship sold 301 Hebner St., Jamestown to Douglas Braman for $134,500.
Mark and Shirley Baker sold 2744 Shadyside Road, Mina to Francis and Dana Schneck for $850,000 and another parcel on Shadyside Road for $75,000.