Sales Include Former City Brewery And Nearby Parking Lot
A closed brewery in Jamestown has a new owner and the Gebbie Foundation has taken over a nearby parking lot.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from July 24-31.
During that time period, GPatti Enterprises, LLC of Jamestown sold 115-121 W. Third St., Jamestown to Wicked Jimmy, LLC of Lancaster for $1.75 million.
GPatti Enterprises also sold a different parcel number with the same address to Gebbie Development, LLC for $256,400.
115-121 W. Third St. is the location of Wicked Warren’s, which opened in July at the former Jamestown Brewing Company.
Gregory Edwards is the chief executive officer of the Gebbie Foundation and was asked about the purchase.
“Gebbie Development LLC is owned by the Gebbie Foundation. The company purchased the vacant lot, currently used as an at grade parking lot on the corner of Washington Street and Second Street from GPatti Development as part of the sale of the brewery building on the adjacent property by GPatti Development to Wicked Jimmy, LLC,” he responded in an email. “The Gebbie Foundation previously owned both parcels, selling them to GPatti Development to create Jamestown Brewery. The lot was purchased to enable it to be part of future development plans in that area of the city in line with the City’s Urban Design Plan adopted as the strategic plan for development across the downtown.”
There were other commercial sales during this time period.
A&M Property Management, LLC of Mayville sold 4457 West Lake Road, Chautauqua to PKTK, LLC of Mayville for $155,000. This was previously the location of Timeless Treasures Gift Shop. Timeless Treasures posted on Facebook that it closed in July.
Royal Casks Wineries Lake Erie, Inc. of Ripley sold 9177 Old Route 20, Ripley to Knight Family, LLC of Ripley for $510,000. The sale includes three parcels, totaling around 230 acres of land.
Webbs Harbor Restaurant and Bowling Lanes, Inc. sold 147 & 153 West Lake Road, Mayville, to 14753 West Lake, LLC of Mayville for $350,000. This appears to be a private residence with a gallery/storage building.
The Upper New York Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church sold 3969 Route 394, North Harmony to Magnolia 1898, LLC of Ashville for $99,000. This was previously the Magnolia United Methodist Church. The new owners have posted on Instagram that they are converting the church into a “charming home with modern comforts.”
The largest residential sale was 11 Wiley Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, for $1,586,500.
Including the previously mentioned sales, from July 24-31 there were 23 sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
— 3910 Park Way, North Harmony sold for $950,000.
— 26 Lakeside Drive, Ellery sold for $675,000.
— Residential Unit No. 107, St. Elmo Condominium, North Pratt Ave., Chautauqua Institution sold for $550,000.
— 5500 Lakeside Blvd., Portland sold for $550,000.
— 3527 Lake St., Ellicott sold for $479,900.
— 3389 Bonita Drive, Ellicott sold for $484,000.
— 5500 Lahr Lane, Chautauqua town sold for $475,000.
— 2485 Shadyside Road, Mina sold for $415,000.
— 12825 Seneca Road, Irving sold for $325,000.
— 115 Wigren Road, Frewsburg, sold for $347,900.
— 35 Elm St., Fredonia sold for $305,000.
— 3679 Pleasant Ave., Ellery sold for $299,900.
— 3810 Route 430, Ellery sold for $275,000.
— 39 Cayuga Circle, Chautauqua town sold for $275,000.
— 1905 Winch Road, Busti sold for $265,000.
— 4813 Baker St. Ext., Busti, sold for $261,000.
— 10610 Swamp Road, Sheridan sold for $255,000.
— 12585 Beebe Road, Hanover sold for $250,000.
Overall, from July 24-31, there were 112 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
JULY 24-26
Efrain Collazo sold 13 Bowen St., Jamestown to Taymont Rentals, LLC of Jamestown for $7,500.
A referee for James and Eunice Mann sold 5838 Perdue Road, Ripley to U.S. National Bank for $45,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Diane Elliott sold 60 Liberty St., Fredonia to La Bella Lago, LLC of Riverside, Calif. For $50,000.
Kierstin Salazar sold 19 Magnolia Ave., Ellicott to Timothy and Lisa Eckstrom for $60,000.
The Upper New York Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church sold 3969 Route 394, North Harmony to Magnolia 1898, LLC of Ashville for $99,000.
Barbara Brady sold 11 Wiley Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Jeremy and Robin Musher for $1,586,500.
Robert and Judith Heintz sold 2502 Route 394, North Harmony to Tammy James for $91,200.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Roe Anne M. Faulkner sold 502 Blockville Watts Flats Road, Ashville, town of Harmony, to Alison Halpainy for $133,000.
A trustee of 46 Avenue Trust sold 46 Price Ave., Ellicott to Frank and Angela Smith for $74,985.
Chautauqua Institution sold a parcel on Fletcher Avenue in the Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Alison Marthinsen for $34,350.
Bigfoot Properties, Inc. of Jamestown sold 286 Baker St., Jamestown to Loser Lane for $45,000.
Joan Palmisano sold 3810 Route 430, Ellery to Kelsie Watkins for $275,000.
A trustee with the Angilella Living Trust sold 3527 Lake St., Ellicott to Robert Brill for $479,900.
GPatti Enterprises, LLC of Jamestown sold 115-121 W. Third St., Jamestown to Wicked Jimmy, LLC of Lancaster for $1.75 million. GPatti Enterprises also sold a different parcel number with the same address to Gebbie Development, LLC for $256,400.
Randall Sitler and Michael Swan sold 115 Wigren Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Brandon and Michele Yeskey for $347,900.
Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp. of Plano, Texas sold 12 Jackle Ave., Silver Creek to Scott Thompson for $52,502.
Thomas Elwell sold 15 Oak St., Silver Creek to Haylee Grover, Austin Leeds, Malinda Leeds, and Rebecca Lauber for $235,000.
James and Donna Koehler sold 12825 Seneca Road, Irving, town of Hanover, to Justin and Caroline Sicienski for $325,000.
Allan Abbott sold 29 Van Buren Avenue, Jamestown to Jacquilyn Linger for $60,000.
Silas Basdeo sold 81 Barker St., Jamestown to Sierra Martin and Casey Miller for $82,000.
Warren and Karen Pashley sold 26 Lakeside Drive, Ellery to Edward and Maribeth Rick for $675,000.
Alan Hayward, Julie Garvey, Douglas Hayward, and Janine Johns sold 4813 Baker St. Ext., Busti, to Jared McMaster for $261,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Earl Carlson sold 10610 Swamp Road, Sheridan to Lucas and Alesha Trombley for $255,000.
The administrator of the Estate of James Golombek sold 150 Goose Creek Road, Busti to James and Brenda Clark for $55,000.
Daniel and Mary Miller sold 6459 Route 83, Cherry Creek to John and Rebecca Miller for $3,000.
Christina Eliason sold 2485 Shadyside Road, Mina to Victoria Smith and Constance Kranz for $415,000.
Sandra DeJoe sold 6715 Webster Road, Portland to Donna and Robert Kneer for $144,000.
Steven and Deborah Darling sold 3679 Pleasant Ave., Ellery to Ashley Kehr for $299,900.
A&M Property Management, LLC of Mayville sold 4457 West Lake Road, Chautauqua to PKTK, LLC of Mayville for $155,000.
Margaret Topor sold 605 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to Ami Vande Velde for $105,000.
Joseph Bartelo sold 208 S. Zebra St., Dunkirk to Donald Daniels, Jr. for $7,000.
Dean and Cynthia Golem sold 566 Allen St., Jamestown to Tyler Eganski for $88,000.
Robert McClure sold Residential Unit No. 107, St. Elmo Condominium, North Pratt Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to John and Diane Arch for $550,000.
The administrator of the Estate of Michael Kershner sold 311 Charles St., Jamestown to James Cassidy for $105,000.
Ostergaard Lake House, LLC of Pittsburgh, Pa. sold 3910 Park Way, North Harmony to Michael and Rachelle Graham for $950,000.
Nora Ramirez sold 29 Newton St., Dunkirk to Kaitlyn Hoth for $161,250.
Royal Casks Wineries Lake Erie, Inc. of Ripley sold 9177 Old Route 20, Ripley to Knight Family, LLC of Ripley for $510,000.
Mark and Melanie Melice sold 33 Hazeltine Ave., Jamestown to Lena Palmer and Rashawn Turner for $139,000.
JULY 29-31
Melisse Schrope sold 1905 Winch Road, Busti to Steven, Emily and Catherine Raynor for $265,000.
Donald Schmitt sold 12585 Beebe Road, Hanover to Matthew Ortel and Amanda Schummber for $250,000.
Chautauqua County Land Bank Corp. sold 94 Liberty St., Jamestown to Elliot Raimondo for $350.
Jamestown Urban Renewal Agency sold 37 Laska Drive, Jamestown to Michael and Gail Espinoza for $15,277.
Taymont Rentals, LLC of Jamestown sold 760 and 764 E. Second St., Jamestown to P3 Estate Holdings, LLC of Jupiter, Fla. for $200,000.
Catherine Rivera Rodriguez sold 127 Myrtle St., Jamestown to Anthony Lenczyk for $195,500.
Steven Martin sold 119 Longview Ave., Ellicott to Rachel Burns for $435,000.
WDFW, LLC of Rosemont, Pa. sold 5500 Lahr Lane, Chautauqua town to Gregory Drcar and Kathryn Brysacz for $475,000.
Timothy and Jennifer Murphy sold 3389 Bonita Drive, Ellicott to Ryan Barrett and Julianne Friend for $484,000.
Robert Allessi and Hao Huang-Alessi sold 130 S. Pangolin St., Dunkirk to Holly Peters for $182,500.
Betty Zmuda sold 140 W. Main St., Westfield to James Rizzo for $15,000.
Andrew Dracup sold 8 Orr St., Jamestown to James Dracup for $60,000.
Webbs Harbor Restaurant and Bowling Lanes, Inc. sold 147 & 153 West Lake Road, Mayville, to 14753 West Lake, LLC of Mayville for $350,000.
Elmer and Anna Coblentz, and John and Edna Hershberger sold 687 Pinner Road, Cherry Creek to Donna Andrzejewski for $160,000.
Jeffrey Franklin sold 11309 Walnut Road, Sheridan to Daniel and Samantha Vanszewski for $50,000.
Elite Image Management, LLC of Forestville sold 39 Clinton Ave., Fredonia to Northeastern Property Group, LLC of Fredonia for $194,075.
Jason Miller sold 10 Rumsey St., Silver Creek to Jessica Dieteman for $165,000.
Robert and Lisa Ashe sold 39 Cayuga Circle, Chautauqua town to James and Kim Navagh for $275,000.
Douglas and Cheryl Gustafson sold 2848 Greenhurst Ave., Ellery to Carrie and Peter Tolman for $235,000.
High Alpine Properties, LLC of Bend, Oregon sold 8 Locust St., Jamestown to Sam D. Robinson IV for $132,000.
Michael Mackey, Diana Mackey and Leslee Marsh sold 815-817 Washington St., Jamestown to Minas Estates, LLC of Jamestown for $25,000.
David Lepley sold 32 Whitley Ave., Jamestown to Greg Barber for $12,000.
Laura Leighton sold 265 Creek Road, Busti to Thomas Brunacini for $385,900.
Chester and Sarah Bricker sold 7638 Route 474, Clymer to John and Katie Byler for $116,000.
Beverly Strauser sold 4305 Webster Road, Pomfret to Eric Swoyer for $139,900.
Anthony and Amy Bartholomew sold 5500 Lakeside Blvd., Portland to Joseph and Jessica Gugino for $550,000.
Michael and Rachel Wilcox sold 117 Hunt Road, Ellicott to Brett Canfield and Leslie Loverme for $150,000.
Devin Cruea and Sara Cruea sold 768 Oak Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Carol Overturf for $215,000.
Adam and Sarah Luebke sold 35 Elm St., Fredonia to Kathleen Tyszko for $305,000.
Jonathan Cairo sold 805 Jefferson St., Jamestown to Robert Fritz for $47,000.