Real Estate Sales Include New Gerry Store, Downtown Westfield Business
A newly constructed dollar store in the southern end of the county has been sold.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Sept. 21-30.
During that time period, Broadway Group, LLC of Huntsville, Alabama sold 4041 Rt. 60, Gerry to NS Retail Holdings, LLC of Dallas, Texas for $1,841,784. This is the location of Dollar General, which opened in September.
That was not the only business sale. Virginia Buffa sold 9-11 East Main St., Westfield to Lux Moore Park Penthouse, LLC of Scottsdale, Ariz. for $300,000. This is the location of Peaceful Designs Pottery & Specialty Gifts in Westfield.
Also, Hungry Horse, LLC of Bemus Point sold 812 Foote Ave., Jamestown to Douglas Lindquist for $100,000. This is the location of Allstate Insurance.
There were two residential sales in Chautauqua Institution that both topped $1 million. 43 N. Lake Drive sold for $1.6 million, while 11 Root Ave. sold for $1,292,000.
Also, the First Lutheran Church of Jamestown, NY sold three parcels on Chandler Street, Jamestown, to the Jamestown City School District for $225,000. In May of 2022, residents in the Jamestown Public School District approved a proposition to allow the school district to purchase the parcels owned by the church for parking space for the high school.
Finally, 150 W. Main St., Brocton was sold for $295,000. This is described on line as a 10-unit income property with 16 bedrooms total.
Including the sales previously mentioned, from Sept. 21-30, there were 18 sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
— 6173 Terrace Ave., Chautauqua town sold for $939,000.
— 60 Crescent Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, sold for $935,000.
— 12 Peck Ave., Chautauqua Institution sold for $752,500.
— Unit C104, Bemus Bay Condominium, 50 Lakeside Drive, Bemus Point sold for $686,500.
— 2412 Lakeside Drive, Busti sold for $650,000.
— 1 Stoneman Ave., Lakewood sold for $539,000.
— 5766 Magnolia Road, Chautauqua town sold for $490,220.
— 3351 Bonita Drive, Ellicott for $459,900.
— 7852 Freeman Road, Sherman sold for $449,000.
— Home F2, NorthShore at Chautauqua, 20 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution, sold for $385,000.
— 5522 lakeside Boulevard, Van Buren Point, town of Portland, sold for $375,000.
— Condominium Unit A-5, Chautauqua Lake Estates, East Lake Road, Chautauqua town sold for $282,000.
— 39 Nash Ave., Frewsburg, town of Carroll sold for $250,000.
From Sept. 21-30, there were 123 transactions total. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
SEPT. 21-22
Thomas Petersen sold 5865 South Stockton-Cassadaga Road, Stockton to Eugene Czyz Jr. for $50,000.
Kim Marsh sold 2962 Hooker Road, Charlotte to Robert Kennelley for $172,000.
Timothy Corson sold 6781 Union St., Cherry Creek to Nicholas Syracuse for $25,000.
Lance Spicer sold 32 West James St., Falconer to Randi Green for $115,360.
David and Ruthie Burkholder sold 7852 Freeman Road, Sherman to Thomas Castle for $449,000.
Wilam Wisner sold 305 Crescent St., Jamestown to Joshua Taylor-Zavala for $1,500.
Rick Martin sold 445 Winsor St., Jamestown to Holly Wescott and James Black for $53,000.
Alex David and Tina LaFalce sold 29 N. Zebra St., Dunkirk to Jonathan Storm and Kate Mahoney for $38,000.
Joseph and Loretta Lewandowski sold 3351 Bonita Drive, Ellicott to David and Colleen Steward for $459,900.
Michael Benjamin sold 3913 S. Everett St. to Bridle Trail, LLC of Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio for $181,000.
Timothy Black, Deanna Black, and Beth Hocking sold 4509 Warner Bay Road, Ellery to Timothy and Michelle Black for $240,000.
Henry Smith Jr. sold 6527 Woleben Road, Portland to Walter and Janice Montague for $132,500.
Rom Real Estate Holdings, LLC of Fredonia sold 2819 Greenhurst Ave., Ellery to Cody and Amber Crosby for $33,000.
Kenia Yanira Ciraulo sold 39 N. Pangolin St., Dunkirk to Jacob Selig for $230,000.
Gerald Haglund and Cynthia McCarey-Haglund sold 135 Connecticut Ave., Jamestown to Robert and Donna Tracy for $130,000.
Barbara McArthur sold 57 Blanchard St., Jamestown to Edilis Melo Lara for $92,000.
Nancy Jopek sold 616 McKinley Ave., Dunkirk to Duncan Smith for $100,000.
Lucky7 Ventures LLC of Orchard Park sold 2412 Lakeside Drive, Busti to Cory and Kara McAllister for $650,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Randall Hopkins sold 682 W. Second St., Kennedy, town of Poland, to Steven and Bonnita Wallace for $33,000.
Dawn Steele Dawson sold 5720 Lewis Road, Ellery to David Vogt Jr., Heather Schreiner and Samuel Carlson for $17,857.
Chad Rizzo, Angeline Rizzo, Carolyn Anne Alessi, Timothy Alessi, and Todd Alessi sold 56 Cottage St., Fredonia to Gerald Tramuta for $155,000.
Trustees of the John W. Hoyt and Adaire L. Hoyt Joint Revocable Trust sold Home F2, NorthShore at Chautauqua, 20 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Trustees of the Patrick and Jeannette Clare Stephenson Revocable Trust for $385,000.
Carter and Katelyn Obergfell sold 20 Harmon Ave., Ellery to Trevor and Torey Honey for $131,500.
Kelcie and Rebecca Brown sold 489 Front St., Jamestown to Terry Ayers for $90,000.
Theodore and Carolyn Salchak sold 5559 Rt. 76, Ripley to Michael Albanese for $110,000.
Stephanie Madison sold 30 Peerless St., Brocton to Paul Grimmer Jr. for $180,250.
Frederick Santucci sold a parcel on Johnson Road, Ellicott to Daniel and Bethany Seastrum for $20,000 and a different parcel on Johnson Road to Lakeside Wash-Power Cleaning, LLC of Jamestown for $20,000.
Dyan Ingrao sold 56 Arden Parkway to Daniel Torres for $115,000.
Jeffrey Pifer sold 5040 Johnson Road, Ripley to Gordon Jr. and Melissa Carris for $12,500.
Tammy Arnone sold 282 Fairmount Ave., Jamestown to Charles Salvatore LaPlaca for $56,500.
CHQRetreat, LLC of Longboat Key, Florida sold 60 Crescent Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to trustees of the J&D Laird Family Trust for $935,000.
SEPT. 25-29
Aubrey Cunningham sold 84 Cleveland Ave., Fredonia to Wendy and Charles Thompson for $95,000.
Jeffrey and Forrest Klarner sold two parcels on Clark Street, Jamestown to Matt Fisher for $3,000.
The executors of the last will and testament of John Hamilton Rogers sold 43 N. Lake Drive, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to 43 North Lake LLC of Miami, Fla. for $1.6 million.
Jamestown Urban Renewal Agency sold 35 Laska Drive, Jamestown to Theresa Klein for $14,200.
Yolanda Thomas sold 433 Allen St., Jamestown to Maurice Akins for $7,500.
The First Lutheran Church of Jamestown, NY sold three parcels on Chandler Street, Jamestown to the Jamestown City School District for $225,000.
The administrator for the Estate of Tracy Labelle sold 6 Sampson St., Jamestown to David Lipari for $30,001.
Zackary Joiner sold 59 W. Green St., Dunkirk to Eric and Danielle Schuster for $218,000.
Austin Rusert sold Unit C104, Bemus Bay Condominium, 50 Lakeside Drive, Bemus Point for $686,500.
The administrator of the Estate of Mark Bergum sold 1204 Stewart Ave., Hanover to Peter and Denise Wierzba for $455,000.
Tina LaFalce and Alex David sold 20 Washington St., Silver Creek to Alex David for $85,000.
Justin and Michaela Kendall sold 33 Prospect St., Fredonia to Tina LaFalce for $110,135.
Todd Smith sold 556 Southside Ave., Cherry Creek to Michael and Dawnmarie Doetterl for $6,200.
Gary and Eileen Lash sold 116 Seymour St., Fredonia to Brianna Leber and Corey Gray for $170,000.
The executors of the Estate of Shirley A. Tyma sold 601 Rt. 83, Villenova to David Jr. and Dakota Meinzer for $170,400.
Paul and Mira Fruehauf sold a parcel on Tarbox Road, Arkwright to Christopher and Tammieann Wichlacz for $30,000 and a different parcel on Tarbox Road for $10,000.
Gloria Lehner sold 5522 lakeside Boulevard, Van Buren Point, town of Portland, to Charles Farina for $375,000.
Orlando J. Pagan Rodriguez sold 523 Main St., Dunkirk to Edith M. Diaz Reyes for $90,000.
Steven Glasier sold 10242 McAllister Road, Pomfret to Justin and Michaela Kendall for $160,000.
Tonya Hunzinger sold 10 Thayer St., Jamestown to Codie Swartz for $16,000.
Joan Carol Webb sold 1 Shore Drive, Chautauqua town to Richard Webb for $192,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Elaine Lucile Cook sold three parcels on Shadyside Road, Mina to William Wolfe and the Jan W. Proctor Revocable Trust for $35,000.
Virginia Buffa sold 9-11 East Main St., Westfield to Lux Moore Park Penthouse, LLC of Scottsdale, Ariz. for $300,000.
Lawrence King Jr. sold 15 Carolina St., Jamestown to Christina Breen for $70,000.
Barbara Carr sold 137 South Jerboa St., Dunkirk to William Roum and Amber Szopinski for $95,000.
The Ronald M. Diner Trust sold Unit No. 12, Ramble Condominium, 40-44 Ramble Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to trustees with The Bike Rack Revocable Trust for $221,000.
Michael and Tamara Engle sold two parcels on Rt. 76., Ripley to Marvin Troyer for $159,000.
Jessica Rogers sold 23 Howard St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Scott Slade for $77,000.
Patrick Dole, Craig Dole, Cynthia McEntarfer, and Patrick Dole sold 38 South St., Panama, to Enos and Michelle Neyman for $172,000.
Ashley Thomas sold 9 Lamont St., Jamestown to Harold Eberhart for $101,000.
Richard Harner sold Unit R-6, Packard Estates Condominium II, 12 W. Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Daniel and Laura Rifkin for $230,000.
Mathew Pickup sold 5200 Thornton Road, Ellington to Bridgett Marsh and Morgan Pitts for $148,000.
Kerry Murphy and Kim Weibel Murphy sold 3012 Rt. 83, Arkwright, to Thomas Pielecha for $175,000.
Christopher and Cassandra Ryder sold a parcel in Arkwright to Bridget Cutler for $14,250.
Eugene and Lynn Steele sold 39 Nash Ave., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Terry Gray for $250,000.
Thomas Kelsey sold 150 W. Main St., Brocton to Northeaster Property Group, LLC, Fredonia for $295,000.
Hector and Deborah Perez sold 55 Benedict Ave., Jamestown to Sandra Guignon for $57,000.
Valerie Ransom sold 150 Beechview Ave., Jamestown to Dawn Walton for $167,000.
The executrix of the Estate of Joseph Terrizzi sold 107 E. 8th St., Jamestown to Edward Bosovets for $43,500.
Allen Chase, Lynne Gish and Scott Chase sold a parcel on Putnam Road, Stockton to Jacob Joseph for $110,000.
Lake Shore Savings Bank sold 9 Old Mill Road, Brocton to William Shreve for $65,000.
Broadway Group, LLC of Huntsville, Alabama sold 4041 Rt. 60, Gerry to NS Retail Holdings, LLC of Dallas, Texas for $1,841,784.
Jacob and Elizabeth Yoder sold 2591 Rt. 62, Poland to Eli and Leah Byler for $80,000.
Rebekka Meyer-Mertens sold 1 Stoneman Ave., Lakewood to David and Marjorie Switala for $539,000.
John Jr. and Martha Grilla sold 243 Connecticut Ave., Jamestown to Tammy Woodruff for $170,000.
Michael and Beverly Grobaski sold 305 Springdale Ave., Jamestown to Ryan and Tiffany Thompson for $245,000.
11 Root, LLC of Atlanta, Georgia sold 11 Root Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to John and Jessica Turney for $1,292,000.
Hungry Horse, LLC of Bemus Point sold 812 Foote Ave., Jamestown to Douglas Lindquist for $100,000.
Will and Elizabeth Martin sold 12 Peck Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua to William III and Mikell Schenck for $752,500.
William Watson sold 5766 Magnolia Road, Chautauqua town, to Andrew and Andrea Esch for $490,220.
Thomas Monahan, Mary Ramsey, and Timothy Monahan sold 116 West Chestnut St., Dunkirk to Richard and Karen Catalano for $200,000.
Sanmar Woodlands, LLC of North East, Pa. sold 5702 Fenner Road, Stockton to Fenner Road Farms, LLC of Amherst for $139,000.
The Administratrix of the Estate of Michael Beutler sold 4 Tew St., Silver Creek to TNT Houses to Homes, LLC of Silver Creek for $85,000.
Maurice Paterniti sold 112 Broadhead Ave., Jamestown to Michael Hutley for $3,500.
Robert and Donna Tracy sold 74 Morris St., Mayville to Laci Weary for $165,000.
Leeann Sunderlin and Rae Ellen Hartnagel sold 2276 Marlow Road, Ellicott to Caleb Jones for $75,000.
Andrew and Devon Gortz sold 179 Myrtle St., Jamestown to Alyssa Rose Kalfas for $143,000.
A trustee with the Winifred P. Richards Trust sold 6173 Terrace Ave., Chautauqua town to James and Sabina Behr for $939,000.
Lois Myerhoff sold Condominium Unit A-5, Chautauqua Lake Estates, East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to Daniel and Linda Jovanovich for $282,000.
Arrows Holdings, LLC of Leroy sold 678 Second St. and 3607 Church St., Kennedy, town of Poland, to LJ Rentals, Inc. of Little Valley for $205,000.
Gregory Leonard sold 129 Superior St., Jamestown to Jacquelyn Chechak for $65,000.
Marlene Joy sold 111 Pennsylvania Ave., Jamestown to Nicholas and Kristina Shelley for $85,000.