Former Valu Home Center, Rand Buildings Sold
A building that previously housed a hardware store chain in Lakewood, and a Falconer manufacturing plant building, both sold for millions of dollars in early December.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Dec. 1-15.
During that time, Valport Properties LLC of Buffalo sold 280 Fairmount Ave., Lakewood, to McFadden Fairmount Properties LLC of Angola for $2.9 million. This is the location of the former Valu Home Center.
Valu Home Center closed its Lakewood and Fredonia stores as well as Batavia last fall. No announcement has been made on any future plans for the property. A different company owns the former Fredonia location and that has not changed hands.
In a separate sale, KGPHJ LLC of Falconer sold 2072 Allen St. Ext., Falconer to Ohio NSD LLC of Calabasas, Calif. for $3.4 million. This is the location of Rand Machine Products.
According to Rich Dixon with the county Industrial Development Agency, Rand continues to be operated by Premier Precision Machining. “They just sold the building and signed a long-term lease. That’s not that unusual,” he said.
The company has been providing complex parts for global corporations in the areas of oil and gas, aerospace, defense and transportation industries for more than 70 years.
There were two other large business sales as well.
MD Gordon Family Inc. of Rochester sold 1215 East 2nd St., Jamestown to Recovery Real Estate Holdings LLC of Colchester, Vermont for $350,000. This was the location of JS Auto Supply Parts Plus. Now Green Mountain Electric Supply, Inc. operates there. It was previously located on Washington Street when it purchased Jamestown Electric Supply, Inc. The company also has a location in Fredonia.
According to the company website, Green Mountain Electric Supply, Inc. provides innovative and renewable energy solutions. They support this effort through a commitment to highly trained staff, changes in technology, new products, and strong partnerships with customers and vendors.
Thom E. Shagla sold 14 Main St., Bemus Point to Scroxton Properties LLC of Bemus Point for $250,000. This is location of the See-Zurh House.
In October, the county Industrial Development Agency had announced that the See-Zurh House was getting new owners, and they were approved for some loans. The See Zuhr House opened in 1960 and it had been owned by Shagla since 1984.
Including the sales mentioned previously, there were 25 real estate transactions that were $250,000 or higher. Of that amount, five were in the town of Chautauqua (one of which was in Chautauqua Institution); four were in the town of Ellery (one of which was in Bemus Point); three were in the town of Ellicott (two of which were in Falconer); two were in Busti (both of which were in Lakewood); one in the city of Jamestown; and one sale was in each of the towns of Carroll, Westfield, Sheridan, North Harmony, Poland, Arkwright, Ripley, Hanover, and Portland.
The remaining top sales were as follows:
¯ 8034 East Lake Road, Westfield, sold for $755,000.
¯ 14 South Lake Drive Condominium, Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua sold for $680,000.
¯ 3461 Old Fluvanna Road, Ellicott sold for $649,000.
¯ 2308 Route 39, Sheridan sold for $449,900.
¯ 5997 Diamond Ave., Dewittville, town of Chautauqua sold for $446,500.
¯ 4473 Chautauqua Stedman Road, Chautauqua sold for $439,000.
¯ 4803 Chautauqua Ave., Ellery sold for $425,000.
¯ 3538 Ross St., North Harmony sold for $410,000.
¯ 27 Waldemere Way, Lakewood sold for $355,000.
¯ 9902 Miller Road, Arkwright sold for $337,500.
¯ 3787 Gokey Road, Ellery sold for $333,333.
¯ Condominium Unit Nos. B-15 and B-16 at Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua sold for $300,000.
¯ 3468 Wilson Hollow Road, Ellicott, sold for $299,900.
¯ Condominium Unit No. J-5, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua to Sunset 66 sold for $280,000.
¯ 7270 5th Ave., in both Westfield and Ripley towns, sold for $280,000. The sale includes six parcels in Ripley and three parcels in Westfield.
¯ 929 Michigan St., Hanover sold for $265,000.
¯ 332 Woodchuck Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll sold for $255,000.
¯ 3935 Sager Road, Ellery sold for $253,000.
¯ 4001 Dry Brook Road, Poland, sold for $250,100.
¯ 10320 Central Ave., Portland sold for $250,000.
Overall, there were 192 transactions, 137 of which were higher than $1.
The full list of sales over $1 are as follows:
DEC. 1-2
U.S. Bank National Association as a trustee for Manufactured Housing Contract sold 5706 Stockton-Hartfield Road, Dewittville, town of Chautauqua, to Keith Mitchell for $66,000.
WNY Properties Associates Inc. of Buffalo sold 27 Parkway St., Silver Creek to Anthony Peter Gorny for $175,000.
Morris and Steven Cheney sold property on Kiantone Road, Kiantone to Henry and Amanda Byler for $60,000.
Edith Rupe sold 7270 5th Ave., in both Westfield and Ripley towns, to Susanne McCall and Andrea Gundlach for $280,000. The sale includes six parcels in Ripley and three parcels in Westfield.
Tyler and Nicole Colbert sold 220 Hillcrest Ave., Lakewood to Theodore Chase for $125,000.
Randall and Margaret Jolles sold 3488 Mason St., North Harmony to Paul and Kathryn Trillizio for $200,000.
Elite Imagine Management LLC of Forestville sold 83 Front St., Dunkirk to Paz Properties17 Inc. of Eden for $50,000.
Gary Moynihan, Stephen Moynihan and Colleen Moynihan sold 683 Baker St. Extension, Ellicott to Jake Dwaileebe and Amber Crawford for $239,900.
Raymond and Rebecca Jones sold 306 Lord St., Dunkirk to Marcelino Hernandez-Lopez for $59,900.
Thomas and Lee Anne Pollaro sold 2513 Busti Stillwater Road, Kiantone to Dennis Faulk for $215,000.
Matthew and Erin Stewart sold 4444 Old Road Camelot, French Creek to Daniel and Jennifer Gerena for $209,000.
Kevin Fox sold property on Chautauqua Road, Pomfret to Shane Krieger for $98,000.
MD Gordon Family Inc. of Rochester sold 1215 East 2nd St., Jamestown to Recovery Real Estate Holdings LLC of Colchester, Vermont for $350,000.
Anton and Marija Mikolic sold 76.5 and 78.5 Main St., Silver Creek to Thomas Holliday and William Holliday Jr. for $42,500.
Valport Properties LLC of Buffalo sold 280 Fairmont Ave. Lakewood to McFadden Fairmount Properties LLC of Angola for $2.9 million.
PPP Future Development Inc. of Alexander, NY sold 506 Route 62 North, Ellington to James Waite for $45,000.
Glenn H. Dickerson sold 1873 East Elmwood Ave. Ext., Ellicott to Roy Tallchief and Tammy Pacheco for $55,000.
George Wilson, Lilla Dell Howard, George Jackson and Isabelle Jackson sold 915 Washington St., Jamestown to Thomas Bailey Jr. and Marvin Davis for $10,000.
A referee for Dennis and Jane Morgan sold 5413 West Main Road, Pomfret and Portland to Benjamin Coblentz for $38,200. The sale includes two parcels in Pomfret and one parcel in Portland.
Sarah Seaholm sold 137 Bowen St., Jamestown to Jason and Janet Monn for $75,500.
Kaleigh Dwyer sold 212 Valleyview Ave., Jamestown to Eugene and Carmela Ann Fisher for $160,000.
John W. Papierski Jr. sold 4 East Pine St., Dunkirk to Eric Luhowy for $74,900.
Matthew Konopka and Vanessa Kroeger sold 3461 Old Fluvanna Road, Ellicott to Andrew Dobmeier for $649,000.
Donald and Norma Deering sold 20 Harold Ave., Falconer to Dawn Swanson for $65,000.
Alan Greer and Patricia Seitz sold 14 South Lake Drive Condominium, Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua to 14 South Lake Drive LLC of Shaker Heights, Ohio for $680,000.
Gerald Russell sold 140 Miller St., Sherman to Rhonda and Boyd Whitehead for $150,000.
DEC. 5-9
William and Robin Bentzoni sold 10451 Creek Road, Forestville, town of Hanover to Paul and Patricia Davis for $124,900.
J&G Enterprises LLC of Fredonia sold 544 S. Roberts Road, Dunkirk to JK Meech Homes LLC of Orchard Park for $26,500.
Selina Phillips and Natalie Garbart sold 514 Palmer St., Jamestown to BNS Rentals LLC of Fredonia for $110,000.
Kevin and Nikki Pierce sold 4001 Dry Brook Road, Poland, to the Riggs Family Trust for $250,100.
The executrix for the estate of John A. Schrader sold 79 Andrews Ave., Jamestown to James Schrader for $64,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Giampiera Miele sold 301 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown to Jean King for $170,000.
MZM Properties Inc. of Brocton sold 70 Old Mill Road, Brocton to Kevin Daniel Gordon for $100,000.
Eris L. Hogue sold 9105 Bradford Drive, Portland to John and Lynn Scott for $129,000.
John Rivera sold 11 Cedar Ave., Jamestown to Lance Weinert for $87,870.
Lawrence Baldwin, Tracy Whitaker and Paul Baldwin sold 9545 Lamberton Road, Pomfret to Junjie Liu for $44,000.
Gary and Mary Anne Thuman sold 118 West 7th St., Dunkirk to Debra Duke for $105,000.
A trustee of the Martha R. Schlegel Revocable Trust sold 1371 West Hill Road, Ellington to Tanner Maynard for $80,000.
Robert Paulino sold 3633 N. Main St. Ext., Ellicott to Charles Haluska for $25,000.
Denise Marie Hayes and Cody Felt sold 54 Armadillo St., Dunkirk to Carla J. Galbato-Kayes for $63,000.
A trustee of the Edith M. Deault Revocable Trust sold 2642 Rt. 394, North Harmony to Kathryn Jones for $175,000.
Megan Walz sold 42 Holman St., Jamestown to Robert and Elizabeth Paulino for $29,500.
Amos and Ella Byler sold property on Scott Hill Road, Poland to Kenneth and Patricia Jackson for $95,000.
Daniel and Amanda Byler sold 1723 Clymer-Hill Road, Clymer to Willis and Susan Byler for $200,000.
John Lehner sold 6610 Lake Drive, Portland to Joanne Cannavo for $75,000.
The executor of the estate of John H. Stormer Jr. sold 1450 Wellman Road, Busti to Charles Jr. and Heather Stormer for $170,000.
Mickey and Susan Graziano sold 9902 Miller Road, Arkwright to Kenneth and Jennifer Sutton for $337,500.
Joelle Woodward sold 4473 Chautauqua Stedman Road, Chautauqua to Mark Rauenzahn for $439,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of James E. Tobias sold 3738 West Oak Hill Road, Ellicott to Eric and Emily Leblanc for $170,000.
Farrell North Properties LLC of Dunkirk sold 21 E. Front St., Dunkirk to Julio Aponte for $85,000.
Richard Robinson sold property on State Line Road, French Creek to Lonnie and Vickie Senita for $40,000.
Hammerstein 210 Enterprises, Inc. of Jamestown sold 351 Van Buren St., Jamestown to White Lion Trucking Inc. of Chula Vista, Calif. for $25,000.
Jack Daniel Deadwyler sold 705 Main St., Dunkirk to Jose Acevedo Santiago for $43,500.
William Corapi Jr. and Frank Corapi sold 4408 Old Road, French Creek to Jacob Althof for $112,000.
Melinda Karnes sold 4762 Centralia Hartfield Road, Stockton to Jeffrey and Christina Parks for $205,250.
Adam E. Melquist sold 9 McDaniel Ave., Jamestown to Angel and Mariella Garcia for $70,000.
Katherine Reading sold 10630 West Sheridan Drive, Sheridan to Emily Elizabeth Narraway for $85,000.
Margaret Clouden sold 929 Michigan St., Hanover to McCoy Five Properties LLC of Lancaster for $265,000.
Betty Jo Zmuda sold 2972 E. Main Road, Sheridan to Robert and Haley Borowski for $177,000.
Gokce Capital LLC of New York, NY sold property on West Hill Drive, North Harmony to Mahalakshmi Balachandran and Balachandran Ramamoorthy for $15,999.
Paul and Sara Trimble sold 10320 Central Ave., Portland to Joanne McClenathan for $250,000.
Pamela Parla sold 514 Newland Ave., Jamestown to Edward Bosovets for $46,000.
The administrator of the Estate of Barbara M. Josephson sold 390 Delaware Ave., Jamestown to Michael and Patricia Fitzgerald for $115,000.
Jordan and Khloud Smoczynski sold 10860 Temple Road, Dunkirk to Kenneth Michael Moldenhauer for $205,000.
The administrators of the Estate of Kathleen S. Riley sold 105 Beechview Ave., Jamestown to Sarah Seaholm for $25,000.
Patricia Leiser sold property on Maple Avenue, Cherry Creek to Yogis Pet Watch LLC of Akron, NY for $15,500.
Thom E. Shagla sold 14 Main St., Bemus Point to Scroxton Properties LLC of Bemus Point for $250,000.
Eliseo and Dawn Quintana sold Condominium Unit Nos. B-15 and B-16 at Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua to Elizabeth and Jason Ferrante, and Bridget Thibeault for $300,000.
Mast & Yoder of Falconer sold 3468 Wilson Hollow Road, Ellicott, to Sydney Larios for $299,900.
Joyce Meyer sold 3538 Ross St., North Harmony to Dawn and Eliseo Quintana for $410,000.
Jodi Hoskins sold 1141 Cassadaga Hamlet Road, Villenova to Addabell A. Rodriguez for $118,450.
Ashley Hinman sold 236 Valleyview Ave., Jamestown to Scott Kemah for $165,000.
Devin Latshaw sold 24 Lakin Ave., Jamestown to Joshua Frangione for $65,000.
U.S. Bank National Association as a trustee for RMAC Trust Series 2016-HC/CCT sold 8768 Center Road, Arkwright to Kevin and Cara Krawczyk for $40,000.
Conor O’Gorman sold property on Bower Road, Stockton to William and Sandra Joseph, and John and Laurie Battaglia, for $9,204.
Neil Burke sold 1004 Prendergast Ave., Jamestown to the Kathryn K. Robinson Living Trust for $26,000.
David and Susan Klice sold 4013 Lawson Road, Busti to Laura Phillips and Jeremy Klice for $109,979.
Brian Conklin sold 104 Barrows St., Jamestown to Mark and Christina Phanco for $5,000.
Iron Bridge Corp. of Akron, NY sold property on Belleview Road, Ellery to Mitchell and Jessica Splawski for $32,000.
Charles and Julianne Peterson sold 27 Waldemere Way, Lakewood to Melisse J. Schrope for $355,000.
Santiago and Amy Beato sold 33 Adams St., Silver Creek to Julie Piazza for $130,000.
Joshua and Kimberly Palermo sold 273 East Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Peter and Lisa Bushman for $249,000.
Gregory and Kathleen O’Brien sold 4803 Chautauqua Ave., Ellery to Thomas and Cynthia Dubots for $425,000.
Winfred Sirianno, John Sirianno, Thomas Sirianno, Edward Sirianno, and Michael Sirianno sold 5997 Diamond Ave., Dewittville, town of Chautauqua, to Susan Marjorie Davis-Gillis for $446,500.
Maridyth Drummond sold 325 Bucknor St., Dunkirk to Daniel Schrader for $165,000.
Janet Bechmann sold 401 Park St., Jamestown to Adrian and Wanda Cooper for $109,900.
Connor Crowell sold 120 Liberty St., Fredonia to Timothy Hoyer for $139,050.
Paul Turo and Aubin Mooney sold 2 Susann Court, Fredonia, to Mickey and Susan Graziano for $155,000.
Doris Gernovich sold property on Clymer Sherman Road, Clymer to Leonard and Mary Jo Neckers for $75,000.
Jeffrey and Vicki Cunningham sold 179 Seymour St., Fredonia to Nicholas Stern and Alycia Willoughby for $160,000.
Donald Cotter sold 532 Deer St., Dunkirk to James Patterson for $30,000.
DEC. 12-15
Keith Clelland and Stephanie Lynn Miller-Clelland sold 3787 Gokey Road, Ellery to Kathryn and Jeffery Kisak for $333,333.
J&W Holder Inc. of North Tonawanda sold 7750 Reagan Road, French Creek to Danny and Clara Wengerd for $10,000.
Burgess Rentalz, LLC of Jamestown sold 165 Park St., Jamestown to Gregory Barlow for $50,000.
Matthew and Leslie McNaughtan sold 2308 Route 39, Sheridan, to Joseph and Melissa Salamon for $449,900.
Paul Lashomb sold 6998 Bowers Road, Stockton to Joseph and Jennifer Saraceno for $140,000.
Phyllis Mucha sold 67 Otter St., Dunkirk to Michael and Mary Jo Kujawa for $187,000.
Jeffrey Rotunda and April Carey-Rotunda sold 3935 Sager Road, Ellery to Dawayne Heiden and Dawn Block for $253,000.
Nora Goetzinger, Brenda Guzowski and Mark Cuzzola sold property on Route 430, Mina to Jessica and Stephen Burick for $51,000.
James Ressler, Annemarie Ressler and Dale Ellington sold 8323 East Forest Ave., Portland to Miranda Ressler for $60,000.
An administrator of the Estate of Ramona W. Rublee-Evans sold 729 Warren Road, Carroll to William and Pamela Thomas for $48,500.
The executor of the Estate of Janette H. Faulk sold 293 Sampson St., Jamestown to Arthur Chamberlin and Michael Kibbler for $92,000.
Andrew and Merideth Ekstrom sold 332 Woodchuck Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll to Thomas Michael Mendes III for $255,000.
Michael Dunn sold 516 Jefferson St., Jamestown to Tamra Tobias for $57,700.
The executors of the Last Will and Testament of Judith A. Hopkins sold 4660 Bemus Ellery Road, Ellery to Andrew and Elizabeth Calavano for $219,000.
Robert A. Rauh Jr. sold 10 Highland Ave., Lakewood to Antoinette Lukasik for $135,000.
Justin and Alyssa Steward sold 8 McKinley Ave., Jamestown to Jackie Smith for $80,000.
Kayla and Nicholas Troup sold 5128 Thornton Road, Ellington to Mark Cowen for $140,000.
Robert and Julie Girardot sold Condominium Unit No. J-5, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua to Sunset 66, LLC of Highland Heights, Ohio for $280,000.
Daniel and Deborah Rizzo sold vacant land on Nutt Road, Busti to Damian Steber and Chad Wilson for $1,000.
Timothy and Nannette Doolittle sold 8034 East Lake Road, Westfield, to Andrew True Card for $755,000.
Benjamin Meerdink sold 106 E. Elmwood Ave., Falconer to Devin and Danielle Raynor for $85,000.
Kevin and Sheri Edwards sold 104 Ç Burrows St., Jamestown to Robert Russo for $5,000.
Patrick and Tonya Smith sold 7 Lafayette St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll to Trystin Lee and Angela Capitano-Lee for $119,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Roberta A. Adams sold 6028 Rt. 76, Ripley to Brock Vicary and Lauren Quagliana for $105,000.
Patricia Vick sold 16 Osborne St., Jamestown to Michael Johnson and Martin Johnson for $44,000.
The executrix of the Estate of Joyce M. Berger sold 7286 and 7292 Beech Hill Road, Dewittville, town of Chautauqua, to Jeffrey and Sheryl Ridgley for $200,000.
Joseph Costanzo sold 33 Osborne St., Jamestown to Girton Holdings LLC of Redlands, Calif. for $114,900.
Pearl Magnuson sold 2859 West Ave., Ellery to Brett and Jennifer Sneeringer for $137,000.
Jessica and Jonathan Lipphard sold 255 Clyde Ave., Jamestown to The Casey M. O’Shay Reppas Living Trust for $40,000.
Walter Kizielewicz sold property on Shore Drive, Ripley to Stephen Woodward and Rebecca Velasco for $30,000.
Kathleen Krystofik sold 10604 Lakewood Drive, Dunkirk to John Louis Falkner for $182,500.
The administrator of the Estate of Dorothy G. Benjamin sold 4369 Hewes Road, Chautauqua to Justin and Rachel Benjamin for $20,000.
Steven and Sharon Schank sold 260 Fairmount Ave., Jamestown to Ashley Gregory for $69,000.
Stephenie Przepiora sold 73 Dunham Ave., Ellicott to John and Valerie Murphy for $20,000.
A referee for Jamestown Brewing Co. sold 3173 Tarbox Road, Arkwright to Five Star Bank for $10,000.
KGPHJ LLC of Falconer sold 2072 Allen St. Ext., Falconer to Ohio NSD LLC of Calabasas, Calif. for $3.4 million.
Kevin and Diane Sturzenbecker sold 3011 Garfield Road, Busti to Nathan and Tara Walrod for $75,000.
Caleb and Rachel Haines sold 5877 Rt. 76, Ripley to Ryan Stauffer and Lucetta Zook for $175,000.
William and Susan Rickard sold 9395 Fredonia-Stockton Road, Pomfret to Lisa Boardman and Rita Boardman for $142,500.
David Miller and John Burkholder sold 8405 E. Main St., Clymer to Robert and Carolyn Yoder for $110,000.
Kevin and Wende Litzinger sold 6782 Rt. 60, Charlotte to Dawn Green and Stephanie Green for $146,260.
ZTS Residential Properties LLC of Tonawanda sold 726 Central Ave., Dunkirk to Kratos Holdings LLC for $239,000.
MW Graphics Printing LLC of Jamestown sold 909 M. Main St., Jamestown to 909 North Main Street LLC of Jamestown for $60,000.
Aleksandr Rovner and Anna Rosenfeld sold Condominium Unit No. 8013 The Northgate I to Brandon and Ashlyn Mitchell, French Creek for $200,000.
Joanne Slater sold 7145 Walker Road, Chautauqua to Gill Family Properties LLC of Garrettsville, Ohio for $60,000.
Jill Fasso sold 6968 South Portage Road, Westfield to James Maxson for $160,000.