×

Million Dollar Sales Include Apartment Complex, Ellery Residence

Chautauqua County had two real estate sales in late October that topped $1 million each.

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in the county and recently looked at the transactions from Oct. 17-31. During this time period, 48 Main Street Associates LLC of Williamsville sold 48 Main St., Silver Creek to 48 Main St Silver Creek LLC of Lancaster for $1,710,000. This is the address of Mapleview Garden Apartments.

In a separate sale 4431 Lakeside Drive, Ellery was sold for $1.7 million. Realtor.com describes the property as a four bedroom, three bath 2,790 square foot residence on 1.47 acre lot, on Chautauqua Lake.

There were three other large business sales in late October as well.

MBC Development LP of Schuylkill Haven, Pa. sold 199 W. Lake Road, Mayville to The Michael Mattis Taback Dynasty Trust No. 1 of Northridge, Calif., for $845,000. This is the location of Dollar General.

Bemus Point Lodge, Inc. sold 3944 South Harold Ave., Bemus Point, to BP Lodge LLC for $495,000. That address was formerly known as Redwood Ranch Motel.

Shults Real Estate LLC of Lakewood sold eight parcels in the city of Jamestown to Jamestown Import Auto Sales Inc. of Lakewood for $229,715. Then Jamestown Import Auto Sales Inc. sold the same eight parcels to Luv Import Auto Sales, Inc. of Lakewood for $459,430. The addresses are 1710 Washington St., West 18th Street, 50 W. 17th St., and West 17th Street.

Along with the five sales previously listed, there were another 19 sales in late October that were $250,000 or higher.

With the 24 sales that were $250,000 or higher, four were in both of the towns of Chautauqua (one in Chautauqua Institution and one in Mayville) and Ellery (two in Bemus Point); three were in both of the towns of Hanover (one in Silver Creek) and Ellicott; two were each of the towns of Busti, Portland and Westfield; one was in each of the towns of North Harmony, Sheridan and Gerry; and one was in the city of Jamestown.

The remaining 19 sales were as follows:

¯ 308A Lakeside Drive, Bemus Point sold for $850,000.

¯ 7123 Lake Ave., Chautauqua town sold for $679,000.

¯ 10 Judson Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, sold for $557,500.

¯ 5991 Diamond Ave., Chautauqua town sold for $480,000.

¯ 5548 Wells Bay Road, North Harmony sold for $405,000.

¯ 4580 Sunrise Drive, Ellery sold for $395,000.

¯ 3419 Old Fluvanna Road, Elliott sold for $375,000.

¯ 1741 Parkmeadow Drive, Busti sold for $365,000.

¯ 2122 Copper Ridge, Busti sold for $364,900.

¯ 12792 Seneca Road, Hanover sold for $315,000.

¯ 10021 Patterson Lane, Portland, sold for $315,000.

¯ 928 Post Road, Hanover sold for $305,000.

¯ 5682 Parkview Drive, Portland sold for $300,000.

¯ 2194 Route 39, Sheridan sold for $300,000.

¯ 103 Chestnut St., Westfield sold for $280,000.

¯ 4969 Damon Hill Road, Gerry sold for $260,000.

¯ 3292 Gerry Levant Road, Ellicott sold for $257,080.

¯ 95 Longview Ave., Ellicott sold for $250,000.

¯ 7270 Martin Wright Road, Westfield sold for $250,000.

Overall, there were 217 real estate transactions during this time period, 152 of which were over $1. The complete list of sales over $1 is as follows:

OCT. 17-21

Michael Caruso, Ralph Caruso, Joseph Caruso, Adeline Brill and Antoinette Caruso sold 1 Elm St., Jamestown to Luke Harrison for $38,000.

A referee for Yvonne See sold 20 Bank St., Westfield to US Bank Trust National Association for $76,000.

U.S. Bank National Association sold 7178 Beech Hill Road, Dewittville, town of Chautauqua, to Arthur Clever for $29,500.

Amanda Szukala sold Lot 32, Haywood Heights to Brocton-Portland Development Corporation for $5,000.

The executor for Julia Militello sold 31 Jefferson St., Westfield to Karen Murphy for $235,000.

Scott Brasted and Joyce Ann Jacobson sold 91 S. Erie St., Mayville to Piyush Virani and Olivia Wines for $84,270.

Daniel Scapelitte sold 127 E. Pearl St., Ellicott to Dossey Land Development, LLC for $69,900.

Brenda Rissel sold 1921 E. Main St., Ellicott to Amanda Tanner for $25,000.

Eleanor M. Klosterman sold 10 Judson Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to M. Georgie, LLC of Pittsburgh, Pa. for $557,500.

The Executrix for Dolores Szukala sold property on Chestnut Road, Dunkirk to Fred Roberto for $40,000.

Jack and Joan Bertsch sold 7123 Lake Ave., Chautauqua town to Steven Dimauro and Gina Esposito for $679,000.

Ginny Greene sold 2690 Widdy Bostwick Lane, Kiantone to Brett and Chelsea Lanphere for $460,000.

Stephen and Barbara Skelton sold 4 North Cowden Place, Jamestown to Corey and Stephanie Tucker for $35,000.

Kyle and Kelsey Nickerson sold 5488 Hodge Road, Gerry to James Schultz for $220,000.

William Stock sold 37 Norton Place, Fredonia to Todd and Brenda Tyler for $115,000.

TNT Houses 2 Homes LLC of Perrysburg sold 5 Tew St., Silver Creek to Ellicott Martin and Meghan Barone for $190,000.

Andrew and Margaret Malinoski sold 308A Lakeside Drive, Bemus Point to Robert and Julie Girardot for $850,000.

Lisa Smith sold 3823 Rt. 62, Poland to Katrina Bishop for $80,000.

Patti George sold 379 Fairmount Ave., Lakewood to Feni & Novah, LLC of Lakewood for $210,000.

Jeffery and Tammi Alberry sold 4580 Sunrise Drive, Ellery to Stephen Matteson and Ginny Greene for $395,000.

Nathan Bull-Barron Muro sold 1884 E. Elmwood Avenue Extension, Ellicott to Timothy and Audra Simpson for $137,500.

Shannon Carnahan sold 274 Hallock St., Jamestown to Zulma Lozano for $100,000.

Joseph and Lisa McFall sold 444 Temple St., Fredonia, to Andrew and Shelley Brautigam for $245,000.

Jamie M. Roberts sold 268 Prospect St., Jamestown to Shawn and Rebekah Smalley for $135,000.

Andrew and Shelley Brautigam sold 193 Central Ave., Fredonia, to Sara Rodriguez and Walter Gardner for $179,000.

Christopher Taylor sold 584 Frew Run Road, Carroll to Joseph Triscari II for $77,513.

Brian and Nicole Pashkow sold 60 McDaniel Ave., Jamestown to Brett Dunham Jr. for $65,000.

David and Marian Roetzer sold 5682 Parkview Drive, Portland to Gary and Lauren Ritten for $300,000.

Jerry Vargeson sold 28 Campbell Ave., Jamestown to Syndee and Thomas Ball for $125,000.

The executor for David Bolt sold 687 Pinner Road, Cherry Creek to Elmer and Anna Coblentz, and John and Edna Hershberger for $155,000.

Gordon Mackay and Susan Forrester-Mackay sold 5531 Route 5, Portland to Julia McFarland for $30,000.

Sean Doctor sold 928 Post Road, Hanover to Scott and Erin Peters for $305,000.

Kathleen Starkweather sold 201 Myrtle St., Jamestown to Jose Felix and Maria Torres-Echevarria for $152,000.

Darryl Swanson and Ann Wilcox Swanson sold 4348 Morris Road, Chautauqua to Michael and Olivia Mae Endredi for $103,900.

Christopher Keller sold 4431 Lakeside Drive, Ellery to Chad and Angelia Ladcivita for $1.7 million.

Andrew Ekstrom sold property on Woodchuck Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, for $53,625.

Brett and Chelsea Lanphere sold 1741 Parkmeadow Drive, Busti to Benjamin Whitney and Jenna Rauh-Whitney for $365,000.

Michael Straeck and David Korzak sold property on Route 60, Stockton to Zipporah Jones for $39,000.

Mary Borrello-Dee sold 86 Main St., Silver Creek to 86 Main Street, LLC of Silver Creek for $60,000.

Elite Image Management LLC of Forestville sold 703 Eagle St., Dunkirk to Moises Salvador Ane Lebron for $52,000.

Timothy Bagley sold 4685 Morris Road, Chautauqua to Robert Balducci for $10,000.

The executor for Dora Barbknecht sold Lots 74 and 76 Deer St., Dunkirk to Noralis Santiago for $72,000.

Jessica Smith sold 12215 Alleghany Road, Hanover to Jose and Emily Quinones-Visot for $239,000.

Herbert H. Hotchkiss and Herbert G. Hotchkiss sold 6183 Stockton-Hartfield Road, Chautauqua to Wallie and Sally Byler for $42,000.

Jebco OGM Resources, Inc. of Jamestown sold property on South Main Street, Jamestown to Seek First Investment LLC of Highland, California for $88,900.

A trustee with the Richard C. Donaldson Trust sold 128 Miller St., Sherman, to Tadhg A. Bernhardt Gerow for $207,000.

A trustee with the Richard L. Bogert and Alice L. Bogert Revocable Trust sold property in the town of Clymer to Dawson and Diane Bogert for $60,000.

John and Edna Hershberger sold 6454 South Road, Route 83, Cherry Creek to Jacob and Effie Hershberger for $160,000.

Leslie Nalbone sold 211 Elmcrest Ave., Lakewood to Gary Haskins for $65,000.

Bemus Point Lodge, Inc. sold 3944 South Harold Ave., Bemus Point, to BP Lodge LLC for $495,000.

Robert and Marie Verga sold 10 Mattison St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Denise Griffin for $186,000.

Orchard & Pullman LLC of Fredonia sold 95 Central Ave., Portland, to Harley Niel for $39,900.

MBC Development LP of Schuylkill Haven, Pa. sold 199 W. Lake Road, Mayville to The Michael Mattis Taback Dynasty Trust No. 1 of Northridge, Calif., for $845,000. This is the location of Dollar General.

Paul Meyerhoff sold 3419 Old Fluvanna Road, Elliott to Paul Jacobs for $375,000.

A trustee with PHH Mortgage Corporation sold 8 Madison St., Silver Creek to Castle 2020, LLC of White Plains, NY for $21,100.

Don Weaver sold property on Gurnsey Hollow Road, Carroll to Don Weaver Jr. for $75,000.

Kristin Leone sold 5202 Stow Ferry Road, North Harmony to Kevin Capp for $35,000.

Phillip Crowell sold 1510 Dybka Road, Villenova to Raymond Hender for $155,000.

William and Marcie Larson, and Gary and Lucinda Chilcott, sold property on Stow Road, North Harmony to Steven and Denise Jones for $58,750.

A trustee with the Barbara M. Mackowiak Irrevocable Trust sold 66 Otter St., Dunkirk to Kaitlin Ann Wallace for $179,900.

Brent and Valory Isaacson sold 4969 Damon Hill Road, Gerry to Richard Kirkman for $260,000.

Burton Pitts sold 771 Panama Bear Lake Road, Harmony to Aaron Miller for $75,000.

The executor for Mary Lou Feinen sold 3311 Rt. 20, Sheridan sold Kathleen A. Feinen Keddie and Kelsie S. Kucharski for $80,000.

Thomas Greve sold 746 Eagle St.., Dunkirk to Ian Muldowney for $123,000.

The executrix for Richard K. Robinson sold 5548 Wells Bay Road, North Harmony to Lindsay Lenze for $405,000.

Nicholas and Holly McBride sold 470 Ivory Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Matthew and Nancy Heglund for $225,000.

OCT. 24-28

A referee for Patricia Thompson and Victor Ramos sold 8348 Fredonia-Stockton Road, Pomfret to Community Loan Servicing LLC of Coral Gables, Fla. for $160,673.

The heirs of Kenneth F. Sohmer sold 311 Lincoln St., Jamestown to Dominic Digioacchino for $69,000.

The administrators of the estate of Thomas H. Eckberg sold 162 Baker St., Jamestown to Pablo Guzman for $34,000.

William and Marcie Larson, and Gary and Lucinda Chilcott sold a parcel on Stow Road, North Harmony to Scott Joslyn for $68,000. They sold a different parcel to David Beers for $152,822.

Andrew and Angela Thompson sold 2 Washington St., Westfield to Jeff Siebert for $74,900.

James and Lois Turner sold 240 Rundall Road, Clymer to Mervin and Betsy Byler for $65,000.

Franklin Pagano, Louis Pagano, Marianne Bowers and Michael Pagano sold 10 Alfred Drive, Silver Creek to Paul Sarvas and Robin Gotowka for $240,000.

Paul and Jennifer Abbott sold 118 Superior St., Jamestown to Christopher Kelly III for $95,000.

Kathleen Such sold property on Michigan Street, Irving, town of Hanover, to Cynthia and Jack Thomas Komorowski for $40,000.

Trustees with the Warren Family Revocable Trust sold 5125 Central Ave., Chautauqua to BZR Trolley LLC of Cleveland Heights, Ohio for $249,900.

James and Jessie Bloomquist sold 517 Grub Hill Road, Poland to Jeffrey Brockelbank and Catherine Finch for $162,500.

Shawn Richardson sold 17 East Livingston Ave., Ellicott to Joshua Spontaneo and Alysa Papalia for $114,000.

Kelly Moon sold property on Durand Street, Carroll to the Sandra L. Fletcher Revocable Trust for $3,200.

Chad and Nicole Kehe sold 1014 Newland Ave., Jamestown to Stillwater North LLC for $25,000.

Joseph and Susan Mignoli sold 207 Brigham Road, Dunkirk to Joseph Pchelka for $25,000.

Stephen and Karen Johnson sold 95 Longview Ave., Ellicott to David and Denise Neamon for $250,000.

A referee for Karen Logan sold 10-12 Burgess St., Silver Creek to Lakeview Loan Servicing LLC of Getzville, NY for $31,00.

Robin and Rosemary Menshel sold property on Sanford Road, Cherry Creek to Kevin and Annette, and Kevin Jr. Symanski for $65,000.

Clayton and Becky Zandy sold 7043 Bauers Lane, Ripley to James Poe and Sky Zandy-Poe for $5,000.

James and Virginia Grandoni sold property on Lee Avenue, Hanover to Robin Smith for $10,000.

Michael and Kara Kirbis, and Christopher and Toni Jesz sold property on Shaw Road, Arkwright to Christopher and Toni Jesz for $28,500.

Mary Damiano sold 316 Dove St., Dunkirk to Katie Dugos for $91,000.

The trustees of the Ronald J. Galena and Randy C. McWarf Joint Revocable Trust sold 12792 Seneca Road, Hanover to Thomas Miranda for $315,000.

Thomas and Darlene Stahlman and Joshua Stahlman sold 238 S. Main St., Jamestown to James Durlin for $22,000.

The trustees of the James K. Brotz and Carol A. Brotz Irrevocable Trust sold property on Woodlawn and Central Avenue, Westfield for $6,000.

Jackie Calimeri sold 210 Hazeltine Ave., Jamestown to Svetlana and Nikolay Bosovets for $36,500.

Lisa Clark sold property on Cardinal Road, Stockton to Chad Anderson for $6,000.

Nathan Avila sold 10 Eagle St., Jamestown to QDB LLC of Ogden, Utah for $15,000.

Bryan Colt sold 115 Peerless St., Brocton to Dawn Caldwell for $115,000.

Shults Real Estate LLC of Lakewood sold eight parcels in the city of Jamestown to Jamestown Import Auto Sales Inc. of Lakewood for $229,715. Then Jamestown Import Auto Sales Inc. sold the same eight parcels to Luv Import Auto Sales, Inc. of Lakewood for $459,430. The addresses are 1710 Washington St., West 18th Street, 50 W. 17th St., and West 17th Street.

Thomas and Donna Bolling sold 10021 Patterson Lane, Portland, to James Pappas for $315,000.

The executrix of the estate of Joyce Berger sold 7292 Beech Hill Road, Chautauqua, to Robert Kawski for $3,200.

A referee for Damian Raynor sold 7270 Martin Wright Road, Westfield to Alden State Bank for $250,000.

Cynthia Burns sold 3686 Panama-Stedman Road, North Harmony to MRR Property Solutions LLC of West Seneca, NY for $41,000.

Gregory Rater sold 3749 Havercamp Road, North Harmony to Jerry and Kathleen Rooney for $25,000.

Jose Rodriguez Jr. sold 611 Main St., Dunkirk to Francisco and Emerita Rios for $66,000.

Victor Steffen sold 70 Lakin Ave., Jamestown to Maria Steffano for $20,000.

Robin Miller sold 190 Ivory St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Michael Rice for $215,000.

Benjamin Bran and Corinne Stenander sold 960 Ford Peterson Road, Carroll to Justin and Alyssa Steward for $133,900.

Sandro Rodriguez sold 701 Main St., Dunkirk to Francisco and Emerita Rios for $20,000.

Michael and Sara Anderson sold 8695 and 8691 E. Main St., Clymer to Tyler Heslink for $225,000.

The executors of the estate of Helen Porpiglia sold 12222 Old Main Road, Hanover to Nicole Hemmingway for $140,000.

48 Main Street Associates LLC of Williamsville sold 48 Main St., Silver Creek to 48 Main St Silver Creek LLC of Lancaster for $1,710,000. This is the address of Mapleview Garden Apartments.

Jay and Sherla Olmstead sold property on Engdahl Road, Gerry to Daniel and Cherish Ambroziak for $110,000.

Donald Macmartin sold property on E. Main Street, Clymer to Kevin and Deborah White for $5,000.

Martin Troyer sold property on Flucker Road, Villenova to James Griffin and Jeffrey Buck for $175,000.

Michael and Barbara Opie sold 2194 Route 39, Sheridan to Daniel John for $300,000.

Sara Skillman sold 5717 Springbrook Road, Chautauqua to Gerald Wdowiasz for $45,000.

The executor for Douglas Arnold sold 309 Central Ave., Ellicott to Timothy Peterson for $65,000.

Andrew Ekstrom sold 170 Euclid Ave., Jamestown to Duncan Oleshak for $37,000.

M. Robert Miller Jr. and Lisa Schmidtferrick-Miller sold 22 Bemus St., Lakewood to Christopher and Mary Ploetz for $185,000.

Daniel and Nancy Kurtz sold 3292 Gerry Levant Road, Ellicott to Eric and Laura Kenney for $257,080.

Gary and Lisa Katta sold 206 Webster St., Dunkirk to Evelyn Torres for $25,000.

Jennifer Prentiss and Daniel Kruger sold 3729 Straight Road, Pomfret to Jennifer Prentiss for $70,000.

Heart 2 Heart Counseling LLC sold 62 N. Portage St., Westfield to David Mathews for $247,000.

Thomas and Patricia Townsend sold 2122 Copper Ridge, Busti to Alfred and Susan Pannoni for $364,900.

James Williams sold 405 Stowe St., Jamestown to Vanessa Kramarich for $110,000.

Mary Kay Moss sold 627 Foote Ave., Jamestown to Christine Hawkins for $85,000.

David Patterson and Marlene Webster sold 5619 Lake Side Boulevard, Van Buren Point, town of Portland for $195,000.

Brian and Denise Hartley sold 103 Chestnut St., Westfield to Geraldine Hartley and Gorgeous Enterprises LLC of Westfield for $280,000.

Amy Fitzpatrick sold 11 Maltby St. Jamestown to Peter and Dawn Rosenberg for $99,900.

Shane Nusom and Danielle Cookson sold 70 Newton St., Fredonia to Leonard Avery and Brandy Hill for $169,900.

Linda Buchanan sold 162 Ivy St., Jamestown to Charles Smith for $110,000.

Mary Jane Smith sold 48 Livingston Ave., Jamestown to Marcos Melendez for $72,400.

U.S. Bank Trust NA sold 287 Ivy St., Jamestown to TKO Properties, LLC of Jamestown f or $64,900.

OCT. 31

Marshall Brown sold 75 Newton St., Dunkirk to Cassandra Jernatowski for $139,900.

Thomas Barbuto sold 90 Ruggles St., Dunkirk to Homayoun Ghaderi for $10,000.

Rosa Ivelisse Alverio sold 206 Deer St., Dunkirk to Homayoun Ghaderi for $25,000.

Norma Huson sold 12791 Moran Lane, Hanover to Daniel and Jane Thompson for $230,000.

A trustee with the Doris O. Hall Trust sold 205 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown to Sedona Holding LLC of San Jose, Calif. for $50,000. The trustee also sold 211 Lakeview Ave. to Gary and Dorothy Braverman for $200,000.

Jeffrey D. Brockelbank sold 15 Church St., Sinclairville to Matthew Brant Lessinger for $99,000.

Jeffrey Martin sold 50 Utica St., Jamestown to Deniese Buckingham for $55,000.

James and Shirlene Miller sold 225 Franklin Ave., Dunkirk to Jessdaniel Cruz Otero for $15,000.

Vanina New York Holdings Inc. of Toronto, Canada, sold 16 Blanchard St., Jamestown to James Christ for $86,000.

Ronald and Mary Wheelock sold 4674 Ashville Road, Busti to Jonas Burkholder for $105,000.

Joseph and Kelly Sedlak sold 516 W. Falconer St., Falconer, to Megan Fredrickson for $89,900.

Scott and Kim Holmberg sold 592 Second St., Poland to Jacqueline and Antonio Stewart for $107,100.

John and Brenda Giacchino sold 2 Birchwood Drive, Fredonia to AMA of Fingerlakes LLC of Fairport, NY for $140,000.

James and Teena Chau sold 29 Campbell Ave., Jamestown to Paul Mole and Kellie Rodriguez for $115,000.

TMA Holdings LLC of Jamestown sold 82 Beech St., Jamestown to Brian Spunaugle for $44,500.

Sandra Colombi sold 5991 Diamond Ave., Chautauqua town to Krisahn Gren for $480,000.

Jeremy and Bethany Hasson sold 1286 Southwestern Drive, Busti to Robin Miller for $169,900.

Beverly Elf sold 2993 Mitchell Road, Busti to Juan and Staci Hoyos for $225,000.

James and Bonnie Barton sold 254 Mud Creek Road, Poland to Leslie Weber for $150,000.

635 Main St. LLC of Fredonia sold 635 Main St., Dunkirk to Matthew Goodwin for $175,000.

The executrix for Denise L. Hartley sold 122 Elm St., Westfield to Brian and Denise Hartley for $100,000.

Starting at $2.99/week.

Subscribe Today